Generation Anxiety: How Smartphones impact children and adolescents

In the following article by the Guardian, the author shows how constant smartphone use impacts the mental health of children and adolescents.

In his article "Generation Anxiety: Smartphones Have Created a Gen Z Mental Health Crisis – But There Are Ways to Fix It," Jonathan Haidt explores the detrimental impact of smartphones and social media on the mental health of Generation Z (those born after 1995).

Haidt argues that this generation is the first to experience puberty with constant access to an "alternative universe" via their smartphones, which has led to significant mental health issues.

Haidt uses a metaphor to describe the situation, comparing it to a hypothetical scenario where a child is sent to Mars, facing unknown and potentially harmful conditions. This metaphor underscores the lack of understanding and concern for children's development by the creators of these technologies.

Key points in Haidt's argument include:

• Technological Transformation: The early 2000s saw the introduction of smartphones and social media, which, unlike earlier technologies, were more engaging and pervasive. These technologies were released without adequate research on their impact on mental health.

• Addiction and Development: Companies designed these products to maximize engagement, targeting children during critical developmental stages. Social media particularly affected girls, while video games and pornography had a significant impact on boys.

• Lack of Regulation: There are minimal legal restrictions on children's access to these technologies. Children can easily bypass age restrictions, gaining access to potentially harmful content without parental knowledge.

• The Great Rewiring: Gen Z's upbringing has been fundamentally altered by these technologies, leading to reduced real-world social interactions and increased time spent online. This shift has contributed to rising rates of anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues.

• Evidence of a Crisis: Haidt presents data showing a sharp increase in mental health issues among adolescents from 2010 onwards. Rates of anxiety, depression, and self-harm have surged, particularly among young girls.

• Counterarguments: Haidt addresses and refutes arguments that external factors like economic crises, global threats, or increased willingness to report symptoms are the primary causes of this mental health crisis. He asserts that the timing of the crisis correlates more closely with the rise of smartphones and social media.

• Gender Differences: The article highlights how social media disproportionately affects girls, exacerbating issues of self-esteem and social comparison. Boys are more affected by online gaming and a general withdrawal from real-world interactions.

• Parental Struggles: Parents face constant battles to limit their children's use of these technologies, often feeling powerless against the pervasive influence of smartphones and social media.

• Proposed Solutions: Haidt suggests collective action to delay children's exposure to smartphones and social media:
  

• 
  

• No smartphones before age 14.

• No social media before age 16.

• Implementing phone-free schools.

• Encouraging more unsupervised play and childhood independence.

Haidt believes that these measures, if adopted widely and collectively, could significantly improve adolescent mental health. He emphasizes the urgency of these actions in light of upcoming technologies that could further immerse and addict young users.